ADHD, ASD and disability ADHD, ASD and disability

ADHD, ASD and disability

This case is a useful reminder about the meaning of disability in the Equality Act and the matters that expert evidence must address.  Stedman...
A Day in the Life of a Town Planning Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Town Planning Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Town Planning Expert Witness

Susan Jones, founder of SJ Consultancy, has been a town planning consultant for over 40 years. As an Expert Witness, she provides evidence at public...
Most unsatisfactory expert paediatric evidence Most unsatisfactory expert paediatric evidence

Most unsatisfactory expert paediatric evidence

For paediatricians this is an example of how not to conduct an expert paediatric assessment and present the results to the court. It also illustrates...
Email chains, gross misconduct and the experts who count the cost Email chains, gross misconduct and the experts who count the cost

Email chains, gross misconduct and the experts who count the cost

Mrs Justice Joanna Smith provides an incredibly useful judgment following the hearing at the High Court in March of this year. Previous case law...
AI and the Expert Witness AI and the Expert Witness

AI and the Expert Witness

It’s impossible to ignore Artificial Intelligence (AI) which suddenly exploded into the public conscious a couple of years ago with the launch...
Review of Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims Review of Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims

Review of Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims

The Civil Justice Council (‘CJC’) is intending to review its ‘Guidance for the instruction of experts in civil claims’ with a...
Update on EWI Advocacy Update on EWI Advocacy

Update on EWI Advocacy

One of the key roles of the Expert Witness Institute (‘EWI’) is to ensure that policy, rule and regulatory changes are informed by the...
Podcast Episode 13: Long-Standing Policy Issues Podcast Episode 13: Long-Standing Policy Issues

Podcast Episode 13: Long-Standing Policy Issues

In the 13th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast, we look at five long-standing policy issues that have had significant developments recently: (1)...
A Day in the Life of a Plastic, Aesthetic and Hair transplant Surgeon and Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Plastic, Aesthetic and Hair transplant Surgeon and Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Plastic, Aesthetic and Hair transplant Surgeon and Expert Witness

Dr. Rohit Seth is trained in Plastic, Reconstructive, Aesthetic and Hair Transplant Surgery with over 20 years of surgical experience. A practicing...
A Day in the Life of a Digital Forensics Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Digital Forensics Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Digital Forensics Expert Witness

Ryan Shields is a digital forensics expert who has worked in the police and private sector. Here, he explains why he is passionate about using his...
Podcast Episode 12: Expert Discussions and Joint Statements Podcast Episode 12: Expert Discussions and Joint Statements

Podcast Episode 12: Expert Discussions and Joint Statements

In the 12th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast, we discuss Expert Discussions and Joint Statements. Joint Statements are critical documents in any...
Podcast Episode 11: AI and the Expert Witness Podcast Episode 11: AI and the Expert Witness

Podcast Episode 11: AI and the Expert Witness

In the 11th episode of the Expert Matters Podcast, we take a look at how AI is being used by Expert Witnesses. We discuss general developments related...

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

When it is advisable to decline instructions
Keith Rix 1488

When it is advisable to decline instructions

byKeith Rix

The Judgment

Mr X should not have been asked to give expert evidence. He was not competent to do so.

 

Mr X’s primary career was in banking and although he qualified as a chartered surveyor, becoming a Member of the RICS in 1999, he was not and had never been an expert in the field of property valuation. Having been asked, he should have declined to assist, recognising that he was not an expert in the field of real estate valuation from which expert evidence had been permitted. In a rare moment of concession, Mr X said, in answer to the judge’s direct question, that had he been told that the claimant had been given permission to provide expert evidence in the field of real estate valuation and he had said that the claimant should “go for a working chartered surveyor".

 

Having thus failed in his most basic duty to the court to ascertain whether he was competent to provide the kind of expert evidence for which the court had granted permission, in the judgment of the court, Mr X presented an ill-reasoned and for the most part obviously unsustainable or irrelevant argument about the case that had very little to do with the issue on which expert evidence had been allowed. His opinions did not withstand serious scrutiny, he declined to make obviously appropriate, reasonable concessions, and, on a number of occasions, the court was left in no real doubt that Mr X was making his evidence up as he went along, which involved him not telling the truth to the court about how he had derived some of the opinions he had expressed in writing.

 

Learning point

  • Do not accept instructions if you are not competent to give expert advice.

 

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.