Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts

Podcast Episode 32: Expert Evidence in the Criminal Courts

This month on the podcast we discuss some recent developments in the provision of expert evidence in the criminal courts, look at the results of our...
A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of a Flooring Expert Witness

Rob Kilner has spent nearly 30 years in the flooring industry, running his own contracting and restoration business across the UK. He founded Flooring...
Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome

Alleged delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome

Mrs Griffiths alleged that delays in treating suspected cauda equina syndrome in 2017 caused lasting neurological injury. The claim failed on...
At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030 At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030

At 30, EWI looks forward to 2030

EWI Celebrates 30th anniversary with launch of new Strategy.
Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

Civil Justice Council’s Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents: Final Report

The Civil Justice Council (‘CJC’) has published its final report on the ‘Use of AI for Preparing Court Documents’ (‘Report’). With regard to expert...
EWI welcomes three new Board Members EWI welcomes three new Board Members

EWI welcomes three new Board Members

Following their appointment at the AGM in June, the EWI is delighted to welcome Karen Addy, Max Beckett, and James Eade to the Board of Governors.
The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous

The combative paediatric expert remains anonymous

In this case the judge had a number of criticisms of the expert paediatrician and as a result there was a subsequent hearing to consider whether to...
Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC... Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC...

Craigard (Dartford) Limited & Anor v Westbury Homes (Holdings) Limited & Anor [2026] EWHC...

The case dealt with the claim by the landlord for breach of the tenant’s covenants and conditions following the expiry of the tenant’s lease on an...
Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence

Podcast Episode 31: 30 years of Expert Evidence

This month we have a special episode to celebrate 30 years since the Expert Witness Institute was launched on 8 November 2026. We are going to look...
A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Oil and Commodities Expert Witness

Catherine Jago is an oil and commodities Expert Witness with nearly four decades of experience in the field. She started her career at BP before...
Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce

Podcast Episode 30: Mapping the Expert Witness Workforce

This month on the Expert Matters Podcast, Simon and EWI's Membership Manager, Will Watkiss, discuss the EWI's project to map the Expert Witness...
A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness

A Day in the Life of an Occupational Therapy Expert Witness

Clare Cole is an Occupational Therapist with nearly 17 years of clinical experience, who now works as an Expert Witness in the medico-legal field....

Check out our Case Updates and Member Magazine

Looking for more news relevant to the Expert Witness community? Why not check out our database of cases relevant to Expert Evidence or the latest and previous editions of our member magazine, Expert Matters.

News

Clicking on one of the topics below will display news items relevant to that topic. You can also use the search bar below to identify news items.

A relief for Expert Witnesses?
Simon Berney-Edwards 3434

A relief for Expert Witnesses?

by Simon Berney-Edwards

This article is reproduced with kind permission from Nikki Green, Solicitor & Simon Perkins, Partner - DAC Beechcroft

 

Third party costs order against an expert witness set aside on appeal: being able to criticise an expert’s opinion does not amount to a flagrant disregard of their duty

 

A recent Court of Appeal decision will come as a relief to expert witnesses, and their professional indemnity insurers. In Robinson v Liverpool Hospitals NHS Trust and Mercier [2023] EWHC 21 (KB), Mr Justice Sweeting clarified the situations in which a third party costs order (TPCO) could be made against an expert witness. He made it very clear that such an order would only be justified where an expert gave his evidence ”in flagrant reckless disregard of his duties to the Court” [95].

 

The primary claim

In the underlying medical negligence claim, the Claimant pursued a claim against the Defendant Trust arising out of alleged negligent dental treatment. The Claimant obtained a report from Mr Mercier in support of her claim and allegations against the Defendant.

 

Mr Mercier was a general dental practitioner, and the Claimant had been treated by a dental surgeon.

 

The matter proceeded to Trial, however the Claimant discontinued her claim following Mr Mercier (the Claimant’s expert) giving evidence.

 

The Defendant Trust then applied for a wasted third party costs order (TPCO) against Mr Mercier on the basis that, had he, as he should have done, not agreed to act in this case (not being the relevant specialism to do so), then no case for negligence would have been pursued. In that case, the Defendant Trust would not have incurred the costs of defending the case. The trial judge allowed the application on this basis, and held that Mr Mercier should be liable for the entire sum in which the Defendant’s cost budget had been assessed.  This decision was appealed.

 

Court of Appeal Decision

The Defendant Trust’s application was based on the heavy criticism given by the trial judge against Mr Mercier. In the primary claim, the trial judge concluded that Mr Mercier had ‘demonstrated a flagrant, reckless disregard of his duty to the court’. The basis for this conclusion was that the trial judge did not think Mr Mercier was qualified to give an opinion in respect of breach of duty, not being the correct specialism to do so, as a dentist rather than a dental surgeon. The application was submitted on this basis, with the Defendant Trust stating that Mr Mercier was the wrong expert to give expert evidence and that he should have appreciated that, either at the outset or during the course of litigation.

 

Mr Mercier appealed that application, and the appeal was successful.

 

Mr Justice Sweeting, in allowing the appeal, concluded that Mr Mercier was qualified to give evidence in the primary case. He said that the relevant question was whether Mr Mercier had the expertise to comment on the issues in this case, which Mr Justice Sweeting concluded that he did. The main issue was whether the pre-surgery examination was adequate. Mr Justice Sweeting was of the opinion that there could be no sensible suggestion that any different standard applied to the examination of the patient’s teeth and the x-rays to confirm which required extraction as between a dental surgeon and a general practitioner. Essentially, an expert’s ability to comment on a case should not be determined solely on his title, but rather with reference to the issues in question and whether the expert has the expertise and experience to comment on those issues.

 

He concluded that the trial judge’s findings that Mr Mercier had stepped outside the boundary of his expertise in giving his opinion was wrong. Mr Mercier, as a general dental practitioner was, he said qualified to give an opinion in relation to the viability of a tooth and whether its condition was such that it required extraction. Mr Justice Sweeting’s overall conclusion was that ‘there may well have been grounds to criticise Mr Mercier’s performance as an expert witness and to attack his conclusions, but this was not an exceptional case and did not involve a flagrant or reckless disregard of an expert’s duty to the court. On the facts of this case it would not be just to make a costs order against him in any amount. The appeal is therefore allowed [69].’

 

The above clearly confirms that there is a high threshold to meet in order to successful obtain a TPCO against an expert witness, which will come as a relief to many experts and their insurers, but possibly not to those instructing them. In short, an unsatisfactory expert witness won’t make the cut for such an order. The take away is that for an exert to be successfully held liable to a TPCO, the applicant must show that:-

 

The expert acted “in flagrant reckless disregard of his duties to the Court”, as set out by Mr Justice Peter Smith in Phillips v Symes [2004] EWHC 2330.

 

This is a high threshold that will not be easily met, and the scope is to be assessed with reference to the expert’s experience and the issues in question, rather just than by title comparison with the treating clinician.

Share

Print
Comments are only visible to subscribers.